April 4, 2001

Reviews: CD
Jim Caruso Live and In Person
by David Hurst

Typically, the biggest problem with live recordings of cabaret shows is that the magic and spontaneity of the performer is lost in the transfer. That, however, is not a problem with Jim Caruso’s new CD, which was recorded live at Arci’s Place last summer. Indeed, just the opposite is true. His sly sense of humor, relaxed banter and – most enjoyably – great chemistry with
accompanist and musical director Billy Stritch have all been preserved with the sparkle of his live performance intact.

Caruso’s selection of material is one of his hallmarks and his show’s smooth and even progression of songs transfers nicely to this recording. A ‘40’s-style singer with an engaging lyric baritone, Caruso seems completely at home in each genre he chooses to essay. Whether it’s channeling Blossom Dearie in "I’m Hip," swinging a bossa nova in "Fascinating Rhythm" or skewering his own audience and friends in "A Song For My Friends," Caruso sounds indefatigable. My personal favorites would have to be "Boy From Fire Island" (which doesn’t lose any of it’s bite on disc) and the legendary Kay Thompson’s fantastic arrangement of "How Deep is the Ocean," which is so infectious it should be illegal. Throughout, Caruso sounds relaxed and as if he’s having a great time. His banter with the audience is especially wicked in his chat entitled "This Cabaret Scene" and holds up on repeated playing.

Stritch’s contribution to the proceedings is immeasurable and Caruso has found the perfect foil and musical partner for his talents. The "Massive Mercer Medley" on which Stritch flexes his considerable musical muscles would be a disaster in any other pair of performer’s hands. In theirs, however, it becomes one of the musical highlights of the CD. Throughout, Caruso’s understated style is delightful. It’s a treat listening to these guys having fun all over again.